Caroline McAlister
  • Home
  • Books
    • John Ronald's Dragons
    • Brave Donatella and the Jasmine Thief
    • Holy Mole!
  • About
  • Blog
  • For Teachers
  • Contact

Of Lawn Tennis tournaments, Elections, and Lewis Carroll

1/31/2016

14 Comments

 
     Today is the finals of the Australian Open, and tomorrow is the Iowa Caucus, both of which bring us naturally to Lewis Carroll.  Yes, the man who created Wonderland was interested in both lawn tennis and in elections.  He wanted to make them both fairer, more logical, more mathematically perfect. 
      Carroll was compelled to write about the rules of lawn tennis tournaments after talking to an acquaintance who was upset after he lost in the first round and then saw a player much weaker than himself make his way into the finals.  Of course, they didn’t have seeding back then.  Draws were composed randomly, so the best and second best players could very easily meet in the first round. 
Picture
     Carroll offered his solution in his pamphlet named, “Lawn Tennis Tournaments, The True Method of Assigning Prizes with a Proof of the Fallacy of the Present Method.”  Importantly, he did not propose a seeding system like we use today.  That would have been too simple.  Instead, he created a complex tournament structure in which players could not be eliminated in the first round.  Loosers kept playing until they had three superiors, three people who had beaten them or beaten someone who had beaten them.  I am a bit of a tennis fanatic and play in a USTA League and I am now dying to set up a tournament using Carroll’s scheme.  What should we call it?  The mad tea party tournament?  Or perhaps the completely fair and logical Reverend Charles Lutwidge Dodgson Tournament.  Here is an article by Rachel Bachman from the Wall Street Journal about Carroll’s tournament format:  http://www.wsj.com/articles/SB10001424052702304636404577297821444746352. 
I am much indebted to it for explaining his complex system.
     Carroll’s obsession with fairness also took him into the arena of elections.  He wrote three pamphlets about elections.  He was upset not just by unfairness in national elections, but also by unfairness in Oxford University elections.  Imagine a university with an unfair system! Here is an article by Glenn C. Joy entitled “Ballots in the Belfry: Lewis Carroll and Voting Fairness”: file:///C:/Users/Owner/Downloads/NMWT_2002_Joy_BallotsInTheBelfryLewisCar.pdf .
     
Picture
     Wonderland is full of games that are immensely unfair and illogical. Take the croquet game, which is played on an uneven turf and uses live creatures for balls and mallets.  Carroll explains through Alice’s point of view:

     Alice thought she had never seen such a curious croquet-ground in her life: it was all ridges and furrows: the croquet balls were live hedgehogs, and the mallets live flamingoes, and the soldiers had to double themselves up and stand on their hands and feet, to make the arches.

The live creatures make it a game of random chance rather than skill.  They also make it wonderfully loopy and fun and imaginative.  Could Carroll be mocking here a Victorian game that is a bit staid and stuffy?  He wants rules that are fair and that work, but he also loves defying rules and logic.​
​     Alice says to the Cheshire Cat:

 “I don’t think they play at all fairly,” Alice began, in rather a complaining tone, “and they all quarrel so dreadfully one ca’n’t hear oneself speak—and they don’t seem to have any rules in particular: at least, if there are, nobody attends to them—and you’ve no idea how confusing it is all the things being alive: for instance, there’s the arch I’ve got to go through next walking about at the other end of the ground—and I should have croqueted the Queen’s hedgehog just now, only it ran away when it saw mine coming.”

​    
On the one hand, I hear in Alice’s petulance  Lewis Carroll’s frustration with a world that does not work logically.  He was, after all, a logician.  On the other hand, how much more fun and wondrous is a game with live creatures than a game with plain wooden sticks and wire wickets?  Just look at this picture of a real Victorian croquet game.  It is not at all inspiring.

Picture
​    
  ​      I am  indebted to Alice Medinger for reminding me of the Caucus Race and its connection to American politics in her beautifully illustrated blog post:  https://medinger.wordpress.com/2016/01/26/lewis-carrolls-caucus-race/.   
​The caucus race is another illogical and unfair game. Again, the course is uneven and the rules are unclear.

     First it [the Dodo] marked out a race-course, in a sort of circle, (“the exact shape doesn’t matter,” it said,) and then all the party were placed along the course, here and there.  There was no “One, two three, and away!” but they began running when they liked, so that it was not easy to know when the race was over.​​
     What on earth would Carroll have made of this year’s Iowa caucuses?  In Alice in Wonderland, when everyone asks the Dodo who has won the caucus race, he says: “Everybody has won, and all must have prizes.”  What if the election in Iowa doesn’t eliminate any candidates?  What if everyone wins and keeps running around in “a sort of circle” endlessly?  It feels as though this has already happened. Carroll was eerily prescient.
Picture
14 Comments
Anna link
12/26/2016 05:48:06 pm

Good share. Thank you so much

Reply
resume writers reviews link
8/16/2018 06:56:39 pm

I believe tennis is fair in its own ways although you cannot neglect nor disregard the fact that match-fixing sometimes happen in the sport as well. Lewis Carroll is a noble man and true to his principles. But, as an ordinary person who has the passion for tennis, I believe that it should never be attributed and attached or linked to elections. The elections has its own means for determining their victors. But, tennis is a lot different. It requires your physical and mental endurance to be hailed as winner. Nonetheless, it was a great article. Thank you for sharing this.

Reply
australian essay writers link
5/4/2017 03:38:35 pm

Tennis is a great sports which keeps you mentally and physically fit. I have been playing tennis since my childhood and now I am playing for my state. This game needs a lot of practice as it all depends on your perfect aim.

Reply
mangarockapk.info link
9/5/2018 12:43:46 pm

Very nice post, I certainly love this website, keep on it. :)

Reply
manga rock app download link
9/10/2018 02:03:32 pm

You made some decent points there. I looked on the internet for the issue and found most individuals will go along with with your website.

Reply
Anne Kepner link
5/26/2019 10:18:44 pm

Tennis is a great sports which keeps you mentally and physically fit. Thanks for sharing this information!

Reply
192.168.l.l link
5/20/2020 05:40:37 am

Outstanding post! I truly liked most of the looking through. I hope to learn to read greater on your side. I know that you have remarkable look and then perception. I will be exceedingly happy just for this info

Reply
Gay Chat Virginia link
3/5/2021 01:48:36 am

Great blog I enjoyed reeading

Reply
MckimmeCue link
6/12/2022 11:53:54 pm

What an exquisite article! Your post is very helpful right now. Thank you for sharing this informative one. If you are looking for coupon codes and deals just visit coupon plus deals dot com.

Reply
Betjee link
9/19/2022 01:57:05 am

Thank you for sharing! This article is a must read for every person interested in betting and wanted to expand their knowledge about the craft. Check https://betjee.com for more exciting games and unlimited earnings!

Reply
fix php errors link
12/19/2022 06:11:45 am

If you need to understand the causes and solutions to some of your most common website problems. We’re here to help you fix them, as well as provide some pointers on how to begin the troubleshooting process

Reply
abogado de lesiones personales de virginia link
1/10/2023 12:20:05 pm

Awesome blog. This Blog very Informative for us....

Reply
online dating help for guys link
1/14/2023 06:00:42 am

At the point when now is the right time to get together orchestrate to meet in a public spot and give your own transportation. Never acknowledge a proposal to be gotten from your home on the principal date. Ensure you tell somebody ie a companion, where you are going. Your most memorable gathering will educate you an incredible arrangement concerning the other individual.

Reply
ouncetocup link
2/5/2023 10:58:15 am

Thanks for the wonderful blog. Keep sharing like this..

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Caroline McAlister

    Caroline is an avid reader, children's writer, and teacher. She lives in North Carolina with her husband and dog. Check out her bio for more!

    Archives

    December 2018
    January 2018
    November 2017
    October 2017
    March 2017
    January 2017
    September 2016
    August 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    November 2015
    October 2015
    July 2015

    Categories

    All
    Abingdon
    Adam Gidwitz
    Alberto Manguel
    Alice Medinger
    Antonio Iturbe
    A Secret Vice
    Book Review
    Book Trailer
    Boo Review
    Caucus Race
    Childhood
    Class
    C.S. Lewis
    Dita Kraus
    Elections
    Eliza Wheeler
    Emily Jenkins
    Every Campus A Refuge
    Fantasy Writers
    Game Theory
    G. B. Smith
    Historical
    Hobbit Food
    Holocaust
    JRR Tolkien
    Katherine Rundell
    Ken Jennings
    King Edward's School
    La Belle Sauvage
    Lewis Carroll
    Libraries
    Lilit Thwaites
    Maphead
    Maps
    Middle Grade Fiction
    Nerds
    News
    Noel
    Our Lady's School
    Oxford
    Philip Seargeant
    Picture Books
    Quenya
    Rachel Bachman
    Refugees
    Robert Gilson
    Rooftoppers
    Scuppernong's
    Similes
    Sindarin
    TCBS
    Tennis
    Tennis Seeding
    The Art Of The Lord Of The Rings
    The Chronicles Of Narnia
    The Hobbit
    The Inquisitor's Tale
    The Kilns
    The Librarian Of Auschwitz
    The Shadow Man
    Thror's Map
    Tolkien
    Tolkien Reading Day
    Tolkien's Letters
    Tolkien's Lost Poems
    Tolkien's Poetry
    Tournament Brackets
    Victorian England
    Warren Hamilton Lewis
    World War 1
    Writing Process
    Writing Technology
    WWII

    RSS Feed

Proudly powered by Weebly